Research ArticleNeurointervention
Coil Embolization versus Clipping for Ruptured Intracranial Aneurysms: A Meta-Analysis of Prospective Controlled Published Studies
G. Lanzino, M.H. Murad, P.I. d'Urso and A.A. Rabinstein
American Journal of Neuroradiology September 2013, 34 (9) 1764-1768; DOI: https://doi.org/10.3174/ajnr.A3515
G. Lanzino
aFrom the Department of Neurosurgery (G.L.)
M.H. Murad
bDepartment of Preventive Medicine (M.H.M.)
P.I. d'Urso
dDepartment of Neurosurgery (P.I.d'U.), King's College Hospital, London, United Kingdom.
A.A. Rabinstein
cDepartment of Neurology (A.A.R.), Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota

Article Information
vol. 34 no. 9 1764-1768
PubMed
Published By
Print ISSN
Online ISSN
History
- Received July 12, 2012
- Accepted after revision December 27, 2012
- Published online September 10, 2013.
Article Versions
- Latest version (April 11, 2013 - 08:14).
- You are viewing the most recent version of this article.
Copyright & Usage
© 2013 by American Journal of Neuroradiology
Author Information
- aFrom the Department of Neurosurgery (G.L.)
- bDepartment of Preventive Medicine (M.H.M.)
- cDepartment of Neurology (A.A.R.), Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota
- dDepartment of Neurosurgery (P.I.d'U.), King's College Hospital, London, United Kingdom.
- Please address correspondence to Giuseppe Lanzino, Department of Neurosurgery, Mayo Clinic, 200 First St SW, Rochester, MN 55905; e-mail: lanzino.giuseppe{at}mayo.edu
Altmetrics
Cited By...
This article has been cited by the following articles in journals that are participating in Crossref Cited-by Linking.
- Antti Lindgren, Mervyn DI Vergouwen, Irene van der Schaaf, Ale Algra, Marieke Wermer, Mike J Clarke, Gabriel JE RinkelCochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2018 2018 8
- Daniel Behme, Anushe Weber, Annika Kowoll, Ansgar Berlis, Thomas H Burke, Werner WeberJournal of NeuroInterventional Surgery 2015 7 4
- Stephan A Munich, Marshall C Cress, Leonardo Rangel-Castilla, Ashish Sonig, Christopher S Ogilvy, Giuseppe Lanzino, Ondra Petr, J Mocco, Peter J Morone, Kenneth V Snyder, L Nelson Hopkins, Adnan H Siddiqui, Elad I LevyNeurosurgery 2019 84 2
- Oliver G. S. Ayling, George M. Ibrahim, Brian Drake, James C. Torner, R. Loch MacdonaldJournal of Neurosurgery 2015 123 3
- J.J. Heit, R.L. Ball, N.A. Telischak, H.M. Do, R.L. Dodd, G.K. Steinberg, S.D. Chang, M. Wintermark, M.P. MarksAmerican Journal of Neuroradiology 2017 38 11
- Biagia La Pira, Tarun D. Singh, Alejandro A. Rabinstein, Giuseppe LanzinoMayo Clinic Proceedings 2018 93 12
- Wenjun Zhu, Xiaoxiao Ling, Jindong Ding Petersen, Jinyu Liu, Anqi Xiao, Jiayan HuangNeurosurgical Review 2022 45 2
- Georg Bier, Malte Niklas Bongers, Johann-Martin Hempel, Anja Örgel, Till-Karsten Hauser, Ulrike Ernemann, Florian HennersdorfNeuroradiology 2017 59 7
- Fusao Ikawa, Nobuaki Michihata, Toshinori Matsushige, Masaru Abiko, Daizo Ishii, Jumpei Oshita, Takahito Okazaki, Shigeyuki Sakamoto, Ryota Kurogi, Koji Iihara, Kunihiro Nishimura, Akio Morita, Kiyohide Fushimi, Hideo Yasunaga, Kaoru KurisuNeurosurgical Review 2020 43 2
- Joseph S Hudson, Danielle S Hoyne, David M HasanFuture Neurology 2013 8 6
- Alberto Falk Delgado, Tommy Andersson, Anna Falk DelgadoJournal of NeuroInterventional Surgery 2017 9 3
- Ann Liu, Judy HuangCurrent Cardiology Reports 2015 17 9
- Chiara Robba, Susanna Bacigaluppi, Nicola Luigi Bragazzi, Federico Bilotta, Mypinder S. Sekhon, Rita Bertuetti, Ari Ercole, Alessandro Bertuccio, Marek Czosnyka, Basil MattaWorld Neurosurgery 2016 88
- Yasha Kadkhodayan, Josser E. Delgado Almandoz, Jennifer L. Fease, Jill M. Scholz, Anna M. Blem, Kira Tran, Benjamin M. Crandall, David E. TubmanNeurosurgery 2015 76 1
- Nimer Adeeb, Christoph J. Griessenauer, Justin Moore, Christopher J. Stapleton, Aman B. Patel, Raghav Gupta, Apar S. Patel, Ajith J. Thomas, Christopher S. OgilvyWorld Neurosurgery 2016 93
- Osama O. Zaidat, Alicia C. Castonguay, Mohamed S. Teleb, Kaiz Asif, Ayman Gheith, Chris Southwood, Glen Pollock, John R. LynchNeurosurgery Clinics of North America 2014 25 3
- Ramazan Jabbarli, Karsten H. Wrede, Daniela Pierscianek, Philipp Dammann, Nicolai El Hindy, Neriman Özkan, Oliver Müller, Dietmar Stolke, Michael Forsting, Ulrich SureWorld Neurosurgery 2016 89
- Alejandro A. Rabinstein, Giuseppe LanzinoNeurosurgery Clinics of North America 2018 29 2
- Vernard S. Fennell, Nikolay L. Martirosyan, Sheri K. Palejwala, G. Michael Lemole, Travis M. DumontJournal of Neurosurgery 2016 124 1
- Moneer K. Faraj, Samer S. Hoz, Amjad J. MohammadSurgical Neurology International 2020 11
- Fusao IKAWA, Toshikazu HIDAKA, Michitsura YOSHIYAMA, Hideo OHBA, Shingo MATSUDA, Iori OZONO, Koji IIHARA, Hiroyuki KINOUCHI, Kazuhiko NOZAKI, Yoko KATO, Akio MORITA, Nobuaki MICHIHATA, Hideo YASUNAGA, Kaoru KURISUNeurologia medico-chirurgica 2019 59 11
- Ethan A. Winkler, Anthony Lee, John K. Yue, Kunal P. Raygor, W. Caleb Rutledge, Roberto R. Rubio, S. Andrew Josephson, Mitchel S. Berger, Daniel M. S. Raper, Adib A. AblaActa Neurochirurgica 2021 163 5
- R. Anxionnat, R. Tonnelet, A.L. Derelle, L. Liao, C. Barbier, S. BracardDiagnostic and Interventional Imaging 2015 96 7-8
- Philipp Gölitz, Philip Hoelter, Julie Rösch, Karl Roessler, Frauke Knossalla, Arnd DoerflerClinical Neuroradiology 2018 28 4
- R. Loch MacdonaldJournal of Neurosurgery 2015 123 3
- Keun Young Park, Byung Moon Kim, Dong Joon KimNeurointervention 2016 11 2
- Ajith J Thomas, Christopher S OgilvyThe Lancet 2015 385 9969
- Varun S. Shah, Rafael Martinez-Perez, Daniel Kreatsoulas, Ricardo Carrau, Douglas A. Hardesty, Daniel M. PrevedelloNeurosurgical Review 2021 44 5
- Bo Shao, Junyou Wang, Yu Chen, Xijun He, Huihui Chen, Yujiang Peng, Pengxiang Yang, Hongyu Duan, Fan Yang, Lingfang TengWorld Neurosurgery 2019 127
- Seung Chai Jung, Chang-Hun Kim, Jun Hyong Ahn, Young Dae Cho, Hyun-Seung Kang, Won-Sang Cho, Jeong Eun Kim, Curie Ahn, Moon Hee HanNeurosurgery 2016 78 3
- Bryndís Baldvinsdóttir, Erik Kronvall, Elisabeth Ronne-Engström, Per Enblad, Peter Lindvall, Helena Aineskog, Steen Friðriksson, Paula Klurfan, Mikael Svensson, Peter Alpkvist, Jan Hillman, Johanna Eneling, Ola G NilssonJournal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry 2023 94 7
- Mario Zanaty, Nohra Chalouhi, Robert M. Starke, Badih Daou, Michael Todd, Emine Bayman, James Torner, David HasanWorld Neurosurgery 2016 95
- Isabel C. Hostettler, Nicole Lange, Nina Schwendinger, Samira Frangoulis, Theresa Hirle, Dominik Trost, Jens Gempt, Kornelia Kreiser, Maria Wostrack, Bernhard MeyerScientific Reports 2023 13 1
- Jaehwan Chung, In Sung Park, Hyun Park, Soo-Hyun Hwang, Jin-Myung Jung, Jong-Woo HanJournal of Cerebrovascular and Endovascular Neurosurgery 2014 16 3
- Aikaterini Fitsiori, Steve Philippe Martin, Alix Juillet De Saint Lager, Joanna Gariani, Karl-Olof Lovblad, Xavier Montet, Maria Isabel VargasClinical Neuroradiology 2019 29 4
- P. Gölitz, T. Struffert, I. Kaschka, K. Roessler, F. Knossalla, A. DoerflerAmerican Journal of Neuroradiology 2014 35 12
- Beatrice Bisighini, Miquel Aguirre, Baptiste Pierrat, Stéphane AvrilBrain Multiphysics 2023 5
- Felix Hendrik Pahl, Matheus Fernandes de Oliveira, Roger Schmidt Brock, José Erasmo Dal Col Lucio, José Marcus RottaArquivos de Neuro-Psiquiatria 2016 74 4
- Yasuhiro Kawabata, Takuya Nakazawa, Shunichi Fukuda, Satoru Kawarazaki, Tomokazu Aoki, Takumi Morita, Tetsuya TsukaharaThe Neuroradiology Journal 2017 30 6
- Sahin Hanalioglu, Balkan Sahin, Sima Sayyahmelli, Burak Ozaydin, Ufuk Erginoglu, Abdurrahman Aycan, Mustafa K. BaskayaActa Neurochirurgica 2022 164 3
- Mohamed Khaled ElewaThe Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery 2018 54 1
- Muhammad AlMatter, Pervinder Bhogal, Marta Aguilar Pérez, Victoria Hellstern, Hansjörg Bäzner, Oliver Ganslandt, Hans HenkesJournal of Neuroradiology 2018 45 6
- N.H. Hänsel, G.A. Schubert, B. Scholz, O. Nikoubashman, A.E. Othman, M. Wiesmann, R. Pjontek, M.A. BrockmannClinical Radiology 2018 73 2
- Peter Mallett, Sean Thomas O'Reilly, Ian Rennie, Mano Shanmuganathan, Andrew James ThompsonBMJ Case Reports 2020 13 4
- Dong Jin Kim, Yeon Heo, Joonho Byun, Jung Cheol Park, Jae Sung Ahn, Deok Hee Lee, Byung Duk Kwun, Wonhyoung ParkJournal of Cerebrovascular and Endovascular Neurosurgery 2020 22 3
- Michitsura YOSHIYAMA, Fusao IKAWA, Toshikazu HIDAKA, Shingo MATSUDA, Iori OZONO, Kazunori TOYODA, Shotai KOBAYASHI, Shuhei YAMAGUCHI, Kaoru KURISUNeurologia medico-chirurgica 2021 61 2
- Bryan Gervais de Liyis, Stevanus Christian Surya, Kumara TiniClinical Neurology and Neurosurgery 2024 236
- Scott L Zuckerman, Nikita Lakomkin, Jordan A Magarik, Jan Vargas, Marcus Stephens, Babatunde Akinpelu, Alejandro M Spiotta, Azam Ahmed, Adam S Arthur, David Fiorella, Ricardo Hanel, Joshua A Hirsch, Ferdinand K Hui, Robert F James, David F Kallmes, Philip M Meyers, David B Niemann, Peter Rasmussen, Raymond D Turner, Babu G Welch, J MoccoJournal of NeuroInterventional Surgery 2018 10 5
- Alex M Mortimer, Celia Bradford, Brendan Steinfort, Ken Faulder, Nazih Assaad, Timothy HarringtonJournal of NeuroInterventional Surgery 2016 8 2
- Hyung-Seok Kim, Jong-Myong Lee, Eun-Jeong Koh, Ha-Young ChoiJournal of Cerebrovascular and Endovascular Neurosurgery 2014 16 3
- Isaac Ng, Rose DuJournal of Neuroscience Research 2020 98 1
- Michael A. Silva, Alfred P. See, Samir Sur, Mohammad A. Aziz-SultanNeurocirugía 2020 31 4
- Giuseppe Lanzino, Alejandro A. RabinsteinNeurologic Clinics 2024 42 3
- Robert M. Starke, Ricardo J. Komotar, E. Sander ConnollyNeurosurgery 2015 76 2
- T.E. Darsaut, J. RaymondAmerican Journal of Neuroradiology 2013 34 8
- Herchel Clarke, Trevor Nefale, Victor MngomezuluSouth African Journal of Radiology 2023 27 1
- Jason Hostetter, Timothy R. Miller, Dheeraj GandhiNeuroimaging Clinics of North America 2021 31 2
- Carmelo Lucio Sturiale, Alessandro Rapisarda, Alessio Albanese2024 50
- R. S. Dzhindzhikhadze, R. L. Kambiev, A. V. Polyakov, G. Yu. Strakhov, A. D. Zaitsev, I. O. BogdanovichRussian Neurosurgical Journal named after Professor A. L. Polenov 2023 15 3
- Yu Deok Won, Hyoung Soo Byoun, Tae Won Choi, Sang Hyo Lee, Young Deok Kim, Seung Pil Ban, Jae Seung Bang, O-Ki Kwon, Chang Wan Oh, Si Un LeeJournal of Korean Medical Science 2024 39 23
- Leonidas Trakolis, Athanasios K. PetridisFrontiers in Stroke 2024 3
- Pablo Harker, Hoover Quitian-Reyes, Oscar Hernando Feo-Lee, Nicolas Iragorri, Juan Carlos PuentesUniversitas Médica 2019 61 1
- Frédéric Clarençon, Eimad Shotar, Raphaël Le Bouc, Romain Pasqualetto, Stéphanie Lenck, Kévin Premat, Nader Sourour2022
- Qi Huang, Kai Qian, Juan Ma, Meigang Ma, Lanfeng Sun, Xing Wei, Yuan WuSeizure: European Journal of Epilepsy 2025 126
- Pai Peng, Hong Zhu, Xiaofang Pan, Xiangbo An, Yongsheng Liu, Mingyi Wang, Yongjiang Liu, Ke Li, Feng WangWorld Neurosurgery 2025 197
- Abdul Hamid Borghol, Bassel Alkhatib, Roaa Zayat, Naveen P.G. Ravikumar, Fadi George Munairdjy Debeh, Ahmad Ghanem, Jonathan Mina, Michael A. Mao, Neera K. Dahl, LaTonya J. Hickson, Nabeel Aslam, Vicente E. Torres, Robert D. Brown, Rabih G. Tawk, Fouad T. ChebibMayo Clinic Proceedings 2025 100 6
- Jung Hyun ParkKosin Medical Journal 2024 39 4
- Yolanda Rubio Atienza, Emilio Ibiza Palacios, Maria Pilar del Peral Samaniego, Pablo Álvarez Montañana, Maria Molina Corbacho, Vicent Modesto i AlapontEgyptian Pediatric Association Gazette 2022 70 1
- Donnie L. Bell, Ronil V. Chandra, Thabele M. Leslie-Mazwi, Joshua A. Hirsch2019
- Deepali Garg, Mariel Manlapaz2020
- Subarachnoid Hemorrhage Outcomes in an Endovascular Right of First Refusal Neurosurgical EnvironmentJ. Raouf Belkhir, Matthew Pease, David J. McCarthy, Andrew Legarretta, Aditya M. Mittal, Elizabeth A. Crago, Bradley A. Gross, Michael J. LangWorld Neurosurgery 2024 181
- Matthew C. Findlay, Michael T. Bounajem, Robert B. Kim, J. Curran Henson, Mohammed A. Azab, Christopher B. Cutler, Majid Khan, Cameron Brandon, Karol P. Budohoski, Robert C. Rennert, William T. CouldwellOperative Neurosurgery 2024 27 5
- R. Anxionnat, R. Tonnelet, A.-L. Derelle, L. Liao, C. Barbier, S. BracardJournal de Radiologie Diagnostique et Interventionnelle 2015 96 3-4
- Nohra Chalouhi, Pascal JabbourClinical Neurology and Neurosurgery 2014 117
- Michael A. Silva, Alfred P. See, Samir Sur, Mohammad A. Aziz-SultanNeurocirugía (English Edition) 2020 31 4
In this issue
American Journal of Neuroradiology
Vol. 34, Issue 9
1 Sep 2013
Advertisement
G. Lanzino, M.H. Murad, P.I. d'Urso, A.A. Rabinstein
Coil Embolization versus Clipping for Ruptured Intracranial Aneurysms: A Meta-Analysis of Prospective Controlled Published Studies
American Journal of Neuroradiology Sep 2013, 34 (9) 1764-1768; DOI: 10.3174/ajnr.A3515
0 Responses
Jump to section
Related Articles
- No related articles found.
Cited By...
- Adverse events associated with microsurgial treatment for ruptured intracerebral aneurysms: a prospective nationwide study on subarachnoid haemorrhage in Sweden
- Adverse events associated with microsurgial treatment for ruptured intracerebral aneurysms: a prospective nationwide study on subarachnoid haemorrhage in Sweden
- Rare case of basilar artery aneurysm in a young child
- Evaluation of previously embolized intracranial aneurysms: inter-and intra-rater reliability among neurosurgeons and interventional neuroradiologists
- Patient Outcomes and Cerebral Infarction after Ruptured Anterior Communicating Artery Aneurysm Treatment
- Clinical outcome after surgical clipping or endovascular coiling for cerebral aneurysms: a pragmatic meta-analysis of randomized and non-randomized trials with short- and long-term follow-up
- Short term outcomes following clipping and coiling of ruptured intracranial aneurysms: does some of the benefit of coiling stem from less procedural impact on deranged physiology at presentation?
- Low-profile Visualized Intraluminal Support device (LVIS Jr) as a novel tool in the treatment of wide-necked intracranial aneurysms: initial experience in 32 cases
- Optimized Angiographic CT Using Intravenous Contrast Injection: A Noninvasive Imaging Option for the Follow-Up of Coiled Aneurysms?
This article has been cited by the following articles in journals that are participating in Crossref Cited-by Linking.
- Antti Lindgren, Mervyn DI Vergouwen, Irene van der Schaaf, Ale Algra, Marieke Wermer, Mike J Clarke, Gabriel JE RinkelCochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2018 2018 8
- Daniel Behme, Anushe Weber, Annika Kowoll, Ansgar Berlis, Thomas H Burke, Werner WeberJournal of NeuroInterventional Surgery 2015 7 4
- Stephan A Munich, Marshall C Cress, Leonardo Rangel-Castilla, Ashish Sonig, Christopher S Ogilvy, Giuseppe Lanzino, Ondra Petr, J Mocco, Peter J Morone, Kenneth V Snyder, L Nelson Hopkins, Adnan H Siddiqui, Elad I LevyNeurosurgery 2019 84 2
- Oliver G. S. Ayling, George M. Ibrahim, Brian Drake, James C. Torner, R. Loch MacdonaldJournal of Neurosurgery 2015 123 3
- J.J. Heit, R.L. Ball, N.A. Telischak, H.M. Do, R.L. Dodd, G.K. Steinberg, S.D. Chang, M. Wintermark, M.P. MarksAmerican Journal of Neuroradiology 2017 38 11
- Biagia La Pira, Tarun D. Singh, Alejandro A. Rabinstein, Giuseppe LanzinoMayo Clinic Proceedings 2018 93 12
- Wenjun Zhu, Xiaoxiao Ling, Jindong Ding Petersen, Jinyu Liu, Anqi Xiao, Jiayan HuangNeurosurgical Review 2022 45 2
- Georg Bier, Malte Niklas Bongers, Johann-Martin Hempel, Anja Örgel, Till-Karsten Hauser, Ulrike Ernemann, Florian HennersdorfNeuroradiology 2017 59 7
- Fusao Ikawa, Nobuaki Michihata, Toshinori Matsushige, Masaru Abiko, Daizo Ishii, Jumpei Oshita, Takahito Okazaki, Shigeyuki Sakamoto, Ryota Kurogi, Koji Iihara, Kunihiro Nishimura, Akio Morita, Kiyohide Fushimi, Hideo Yasunaga, Kaoru KurisuNeurosurgical Review 2020 43 2
- Joseph S Hudson, Danielle S Hoyne, David M HasanFuture Neurology 2013 8 6
More in this TOC Section
Similar Articles
Advertisement